Thursday, November 29, 2007

Interim Recommendations

Please use this space to converse with other Roundtable members about our interim recommendations. This blog is not linked publicly from our website, so is not available to the general public.

Thanks - Liz

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Draft report has sound philosohpical reasoning for movement of students. It would be interesting to know if in Tallahassee or elsewhere if there has been an analysis of teacher mobility and assignment and if that can make as great an impact as moving students. It certainly requires less gas, would result in greater parent happiness, etc. Also, could there be a teacher corp of high-performing teachers who move with some students as incentive. The crux of the issue is this: greater school choice for parents/students only works if there is space in the high-performing schools. If the high-performing schools are at capacity (and many are in north-east Tallahassee) then how do we incentivize the system (teachers and principals) to work for the good of the entire school district, just not their school.

Anonymous said...

Liz, et al....The liberal conservative split seems to be forced a bit. I have experienced the neighborhood school vs the diverse school as one of the critical points. People consistently rate (PDK Gallup Poll) their neighborhood school higher than the distict as a whole. If the school is good to great---don't you dare mess with it or send my kid to another school. If my school is poor, then the district needs to give me the opportunity to choose a better school. The conservative approach to the issue is charter schools and choice, with the money following the kid. The liberal approach is socio-economic integration to prevent suburb flight and special programs and money to improve the unsuccessful schools. The community education component is good, especially regarding the cost to the community for running the underenrolled or unsuccessful school, the impact on the neighborhoods, and most importantly the impact on the students who cannot afford to move to a better school. Those less than successful students who are in less than successful schools will cost society a great deal later on as the lack of a high school diploma is one of the highest correlates of incarceration and the lack of college means a million dollars less in lifetime earnings.

I agree the community is not very concerned if they think the school district is doing okay or their own school is fine.....Jim C.

Unknown said...

Liz did an outstanding job describing both sides of this issue. I am pleased to "sign" my name to this document as written.
Best, Bill Spann